Worried right now? Please don't wait for a reply from me. Is this urgent?
The Lunar MidwifeChloe Birt, Registered Midwife Gift vouchersBook

Home › Tales and truths › Things people say › "Is she a good baby?"

Things people say · No. 38

"Is she a good baby?"

It's the question every new mum gets asked. But babies aren't good or bad: they're new, and most of what they do is exactly what newborns are meant to do.

3 minute read

It's often one of the first questions you'll be asked: in the queue at the shop, at the school gate, or from a relative leaning over the pram. "Is she a good baby?" Most people mean it kindly.

What they're usually asking is: does she sleep, does she cry much, is she easy? It's shorthand that's been passed down for generations. But when you've been up three times in the night and she's fed all evening, it can land hard. It can sound as if there's a right answer, and you haven't got it.

Babies aren't good or bad. They're new.

Almost everything a newborn does is about getting what she needs to grow, and most of what people mean by "not good" is completely normal.

  • Feeding often is normal. The NHS says a breastfed baby should feed at least 8 to 12 times every 24 hours in the first few weeks. UNICEF UK's Baby Friendly Initiative, which sets standards for baby feeding and care, explains why: babies grow quickly and have very small stomachs, so they need to feed around the clock.
  • Cluster feeding is normal. Many babies have spells of feeding almost constantly, with short breaks, often in the evening. NHS guidance calls this very normal and nothing to be concerned about. For breastfed babies, it helps to build your milk supply. It's also normal if your baby doesn't do it.
  • Waking at night is normal. Newborns can sleep around 18 hours a day in total, but in short bursts, and they wake at night because they need to be fed. UNICEF UK describes night feeds as "both normal and essential". Some babies sleep through early on; the NHS notes that many don't for a long time.
  • Crying is normal. The NHS says all babies cry, and some more than others. Crying often increases from around 2 weeks and eases by about 3 months, and it's often worse in the afternoon and evening, just when you're most tired.

Babies also have their own temperaments. Developmental psychologists describe temperament as the inborn part of our individuality. Some babies are naturally more settled; some are more sensitive or more intense. That isn't a verdict on her, and it isn't a verdict on you.

You don't owe anyone a report card

A few replies you could borrow: "She's a baby, so she's doing baby things." "She's lovely. I'm tired." "She feeds a lot, which is exactly what she's meant to do."

And if you're the one asking a new mum, try "How are you both doing?" or "What's she like?" Then offer something useful: bring food, hold the baby while she has a shower, or put the kettle on.

On the hardest days

What actually helps with a baby who feeds, wakes and cries a lot is support, rest wherever you can get it, and knowing that this stage passes. If you ever feel so tired and angry that you can't take any more, the NHS says this happens to a lot of parents. Put your baby down somewhere safe, such as her cot, and step away for a few minutes to calm down. The Cry-sis helpline (0800 448 0737) is there for parents of babies who cry a lot.

When to get help. Trust your instincts. Ring your midwife, health visitor, GP or NHS 111 the same day if your baby isn't feeding well or has fewer wet nappies than usual. If she's floppy, very sleepy or hard to wake, that needs help straight away: see Is this urgent?

What I think

Every baby is a good baby! Feeding, waking and crying are just how babies get what they need. The question I'd rather ask is: how are you doing?

Chloe

Questions like this come up between appointments. Send them to me and I'll reply within a day, as someone who knows your story.

Between Appointments

This is general information, not personal medical advice. If you're worried about yourself or your baby, see Is this urgent?

Sources

  1. NHS. Breastfeeding: the first few days.
  2. NHS Best Start in Life. Cluster feeding.
  3. NHS Grampian, Birth in Grampian. Cluster feeding and growth spurts.
  4. UNICEF UK Baby Friendly Initiative. Caring for your baby at night: a guide for parents.
  5. NHS. Helping your baby to sleep.
  6. NHS. Soothing a crying baby.
  7. OpenStax. Lifespan Development, 4.2 Temperament and personality in infants and toddlers. Rice University.
Chloe Birt