Worried right now? Please don't wait for a reply from me. Is this urgent?
The Lunar MidwifeChloe Birt, Registered Midwife Gift vouchersBook

Home › Tales and truths › Old wives' tales › A good cry is good for their lungs

Old wives' tales · No. 31

A good cry is good for their lungs

It's an old reason for leaving a baby to cry. There's a grain of truth in the first minutes of life, and very little after that.

3 minute read

"Leave him, it's good for his lungs." "She's just exercising her lungs." You may hear this from a grandparent, a neighbour or a stranger in the supermarket queue. It's usually meant kindly: a way of saying that crying is normal and you don't need to panic.

The first cry

There's a grain of truth, right at the very start. At birth, a baby's lungs are full of fluid and have to fill with air. A 2021 study led by the Murdoch Children's Research Institute in Melbourne found that about 80% of breaths just after birth are cries, and that crying helps to aerate the lungs quickly. That's one reason a newborn's first cry is such a welcome sound.

After that, crying is talking

After that, crying isn't exercise. It's communication. The NHS lists the usual reasons babies cry: hunger, a dirty or wet nappy, tiredness, wanting a cuddle, wind, being too hot or too cold, boredom and overstimulation. Crying is how your baby tells you something is needed.

Responding doesn't spoil them. Unicef UK's Baby Friendly Initiative, which sets standards for baby feeding and care, says you cannot spoil your baby with too much love, and that holding your baby when they're crying helps them feel loved and secure, even if they don't stop straight away.

Some crying is normal, and it has a pattern. ICON, the UK programme behind "Babies cry, you can cope", explains that babies start to cry more from around 2 weeks old. Crying reaches a peak at about 6 to 8 weeks, sometimes a little later, and then starts to ease week by week. Knowing that the hardest stretch has an end can help.

Comforting them

Check the basics first: is your baby hungry, tired, or in need of a nappy change? Then try comfort. ICON and the NHS suggest holding your baby close, skin to skin, talking or singing calmly, a steady soothing sound, a walk in the pram or sling, sucking at the breast or on a dummy, or a warm bath.

When nothing works

  • Sometimes nothing works, and that's not your fault. If the crying is getting to you, it's OK to walk away for a few minutes. The NHS says to put your baby in their cot or pram, make sure they're safe, close the door, go into another room and calm yourself down. Then go back and check on them.
  • Never shake a baby, however frustrated you feel. Shaking can cause brain damage or death. Make sure anyone who looks after your baby knows how to cope with crying too.
  • You don't have to cope alone. Your health visitor or GP can help, and Cry-sis runs a helpline for parents of crying babies on 0800 448 0737.
  • Ring 999 if your baby has a weak, high-pitched or continuous cry, or a cry that doesn't sound like their normal cry. The full list of warning signs is on Is this urgent?
  • Look after yourself too. If you've felt low or anxious most days for more than two weeks, talk to your midwife, health visitor or GP.

What I think

That first cry at birth is wonderful, but after that it's your baby talking to you. Pick them up, cuddle them, and when you need a breather, put them down somewhere safe and step away for a few minutes. Never, ever shake a baby.

Chloe

Questions like this come up between appointments. Send them to me and I'll reply within a day, as someone who knows your story.

Between Appointments

This is general information, not personal medical advice. If you're worried about yourself or your baby, see Is this urgent?

Sources

  1. Murdoch Children's Research Institute. First detailed insight into newborn babies' lungs at birth (reporting a study in the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine). MCRI, 2021.
  2. NHS. Soothing a crying baby. NHS website, accessed 2026.
  3. Unicef UK Baby Friendly Initiative. Building a happy baby: a guide for parents. Unicef UK, 2018.
  4. ICON. Infant crying is normal. ICON: Babies cry, you can cope, accessed 2026.
  5. ICON. Comforting methods can help. ICON: Babies cry, you can cope, accessed 2026.
  6. ICON. Never, ever shake a baby. ICON: Babies cry, you can cope, accessed 2026.
  7. NHS. Colic. NHS website, accessed 2026.
Chloe Birt