Worried right now? Please don't wait for a reply from me. Is this urgent?
The Lunar MidwifeChloe Birt, Registered Midwife Gift vouchersBook

Home › Tales and truths › What are the chances? › Birth after a caesarean: VBAC or another caesarean?

What are the chances? · No. 61

Birth after a caesarean: VBAC or another caesarean?

Planning a vaginal birth after caesarean, or a repeat caesarean? Both carry small risks, just different ones. Here they are in plain numbers.

4 minute read

If you've had a caesarean before, at some point in your next pregnancy someone will ask how you'd like to give birth this time. There are two main options: planning a vaginal birth after caesarean (VBAC), or planning a repeat caesarean. Both carry small risks, just different ones. Here they are side by side, from the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) guideline on birth after caesarean and its leaflet for women.

Two reasonable choices

RCOG says planned VBAC is a safe and appropriate choice for most women who've had one caesarean with the usual low cut across the womb. It isn't usually advised if you've had three or more caesareans, a previous tear in the womb, a "classical" vertical cut, or a complication in this pregnancy that needs a planned caesarean. RCOG advises that a VBAC happens in hospital, with your baby's heart rate monitored continuously in labour.

A decision to make? Ask the BRAIN questions

How likely a vaginal birth is

  • About 3 in 4 women with an uncomplicated pregnancy who plan a VBAC give birth vaginally.
  • If you've ever given birth vaginally, it's about 9 in 10.
  • About 25 in 100 women planning a VBAC need an emergency caesarean in labour. RCOG compares this with about 20 in 100 women labouring for the first time.

RCOG's guideline dates from 2015 and draws on large studies, many of them from outside the UK; the leaflet was last updated in 2025.

The scar: what uterine rupture means

The risk people fear most is the scar on the womb opening or tearing in labour, called uterine rupture. RCOG puts it at about 1 in 200 women planning a VBAC, and 2 to 3 times higher if labour is induced. With a planned repeat caesarean, it's about 1 in 1,000. Out of 1,000 women planning a VBAC, about 5 would have a rupture; out of 1,000 planning a caesarean, about 1. If there are warning signs, your baby is born by emergency caesarean, and RCOG says serious consequences for you and your baby are rare.

Planned VBAC

5 in 1,000

About 1 in 200 women planning a VBAC, from RCOG Green-top Guideline 45 and its leaflet.

Planned caesarean

1 in 1,000

About 1 in 1,000 women planning a repeat caesarean, from the RCOG leaflet.

Each dot is one pregnancy or baby. Figures checked September 2026.

What each option means for you and your baby

Planning a VBAC. You're slightly more likely to need a blood transfusion, and you may need forceps or ventouse (a soft suction cup on the baby's head) or have a deeper tear, as in any vaginal birth. For your baby, RCOG says the risk of serious harm, such as brain injury or stillbirth, is higher than with a planned caesarean but the same as for a woman labouring for the first time.

In a large US study quoted in the guideline, about 4 in 10,000 babies died around birth and 8 in 10,000 had a brain injury from lack of oxygen. With a planned caesarean, the risk of the baby dying around birth is 1 in 10,000 or less. If a VBAC succeeds, RCOG says future labours tend to be less complicated.

Planning a repeat caesarean. The operation usually takes longer because of scar tissue. There's a chance of a slow-healing wound infection, a blood transfusion, and a higher risk of blood clots in the legs or lungs. Recovery is longer, and you can't drive for about 6 weeks.

For your baby, 4 to 5 in 100 born by planned caesarean at or after 39 weeks have breathing problems, compared with 2 to 3 in 100 after a VBAC, and 6 in 100 at 38 weeks. About 2 in 100 babies get a small cut to the skin during the operation. Each caesarean adds scar tissue, which makes it more likely in a future pregnancy that the placenta grows into the scar. That can cause heavy bleeding and sometimes means removing the womb.

A mother dying is very rare either way. In the US studies RCOG quotes, it was about 4 in 100,000 with planned VBAC and 13 in 100,000 with a planned repeat caesarean.

Whichever you plan, ring your maternity unit straight away if you have bleeding, think labour has started early, or your baby is moving less. See Is this urgent?

What I think

There's no wrong answer here, just the right one for you. Think about how your last birth went and what matters most to you this time, then talk it through with your midwife and obstetrician. If your last birth still sits heavily with you, a debrief can really help first.

Chloe

Still thinking about your birth? A birth debrief is time to talk it through, at your own pace, however long ago it was.

About birth debriefs

This is general information, not personal medical advice. If you're worried about yourself or your baby, see Is this urgent?

Sources

  1. Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. Birth after previous caesarean birth. Green-top Guideline No. 45, 2015.
  2. Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. Birth after previous caesarean. Patient information leaflet, 2016, updated 2025.
  3. NICE. Inducing labour (NG207), recommendations 1.2.17 to 1.2.19, 2021.
Chloe Birt